Tax Reform: Revenue Agency Discards Punishment for Good Faith Mistakes
Secretary Says Risks Were Mapped and Companies Will Receive Guidance

The Secretary of the Federal Revenue, Robinson Barreirinhas, said on Tuesday (17) that the risks and challenges of the implementation of reforma tributária have already been identified and that the government intends to guide taxpayers during the transition to the new system.
In audiência pública at the Senate Economic Affairs Committee (CAE), Barreirinhas acknowledged that the changes raise doubts between companies and professionals, but said that the main problems are already mapped.
According to the secretary, the Revenue system has been in testing since January and has processed more than 35 billion tax documents. In the last 30 days alone, it was about 5 billion. The secretary added that more than 70% of the documents issued in the testing environment already bring the highlight of the new tributes.
Barreirinhas said that the main concern presented by entrepreneurs is the risk of errors during the period of adaptation to the new rules. According to him, the Receita defends that taxpayers who act in good faith are not punished for failures committed in this process, as long as they do not hide information or try to defraud the system.
He stated that, in cases where there is a need for adjustments resulting from changes in the understanding of the tax administration, the guidance will be to privilege the correction of procedures rather than the application of penalties.
Assisted counting
To reduce the risks of error, the Revenue bets on the so-called assisted counting, a mechanism similar to the pre-filled return of the Income Tax. By the model, the information used in the calculation of the taxes will be organized in advance by the taxpayer, and it is up to the taxpayer to check them and make any corrections.
"Assisted counting is similar, in a way, to the pre-filled declaration. We are going to end up with a lot of taxpayers’ statements,” he said.
He recalled that the system is already being tested by 500 companies and should be available to all Brazilian companies in the coming days. A simplified module for information correction is also under development.
"It's this simplified module that we're building and we're going to release the pilot now in December," he said.
The secretary also reported that the Revenue identified the groups with the greatest risk of facing difficulties in the transition.
“We map out which taxpayers may have some difficulty. We know that there are 1.1 million small and micro entrepreneurs who may have some difficulty,” he said.
According to him, the requirement of the new model of tax document for some of these taxpayers was postponed to March of next year, allowing more time for adaptation, training and guidance.
Understand.
The Contribution on Goods and Services (CBS), a federal tax created by reforma tributária, will replace PIS/Pasep and Cofins from 2027. Alongside the Goods and Services Tax (IBS), of state and municipal competence, it will form the new model of Value Added Tax (VAT) dual of the country.
CBS will focus on the consumption of goods and services and will follow the non-cumulative principle. In practice, companies will be able to deduct credits related to the taxes paid in the previous stages of the production chain, reducing the so-called cascading taxation.
Parallel to the definition of the rate, the government has been advocating measures to facilitate the transition to the new system. A proposal announced by the Ministry of Finance provides for mechanisms that expand the use of tax credits, including on machines, equipment and other investments of companies. According to the economic team, the measures seek to reduce adaptation costs, give more predictability to taxpayers and smooth the transition from the current system to dual VAT.
By the legislation of the reform, it was initially up to the Federal Revenue to elaborate the calculations of the tax rate necessary to preserve the collection of the federal taxes that will be replaced. The Court of Auditors then analysed the methodology and calculated the so-called CBS reference rate. In October, the court approved the percentage of 11,3468%, rounded to 11.3%.
Tax benefits
The index exceeds the previous estimate of 9.21% presented by the economic team and used in the studies and projections on reforma tributária. According to the Ministry of Finance, the difference stems mainly from the more precise incorporation of the differentiated benefits and treatments provided for in the legislation.
The 11.3% represents a reference rate, used as a parameter for the definition of the tax. The percentage actually charged may vary depending on the type of operation and the benefits provided for in the legislation, such as:
• reductions of rates for certain sectors;
• exemptions and zero rate hypotheses;
• specific tax systems;
• Use of tax credits in previous operations.
Therefore, the reference rate does not necessarily mean an equivalent increase in the prices of goods and services.
Possible revision
The disclosure of the percentage rekindled the debate on the tax burden of the new dual VAT. In recent discussions on the regulation of the reform, MPs admitted to reviewing tax benefits if the sum of the rates of CBS and IBS exceeds the 26.5 percent that served as a reference during the processing of the proposal.
With the completion of the technical stage in the TCU, it will now be up to the Senate to deliberate on the CBS rate. It is in this context that the Economic Affairs Commission (CAE) has been discussing the criteria used in the calculation and the impacts of the percentage suggested by the court.
The legislation provides that the Senate sets the rate by means of resolution. Thus, although the reference calculation of 11.3% has already been approved by the TCU, the final definition will still depend on the deliberation of the parliamentarians.
















