FRIDAY · 20 NOV 2026Ponta Grossa 25°C ☁️
Advertisement
Politics

Dino votes to make Marcel van Hattem defendant in STF

The minister Flávio Dino, from the Supreme Federal Court, voted on Friday (20) to accept the indictment against federal deputy Marcel van Hattem for the crimes of defamation and insult. The case involves offenses made by the parliamentarian against Federal Police officer Fábio Shor. The final decision still depends on the other justices of the Court.

Dino vota por tornar Marcel van Hattem réu no STF
Crédito: www.gazetadopovo.com.br
Advertisement

Minister Flávio Dino of Supremo Tribunal Federal (STF) voted on Friday, November 20, 2026, to accept the complaint against federal deputy Marcel van Hattem for the crimes of slander and insult. The case is processed in the Court and was motivated by offenses profered by the parliamentary against the Federal Police delegate Fábio Shor. Van Hattem accused the police officer of abusing authority and fabricating fraudulent reports.

With Dino’s vote, the process moves to the analysis phase by the other ministers of the STF. If the majority follows the rapporteur, the deputy will become a defendant and will respond to a criminal action in the Supreme Court itself. The complaint was filed by the Attorney General's Office (PGR), which pointed to the practice of both crimes against the honor of the delegate.

Understand the charges against the Member

The parliamentarian is accused of the crimes of slander and insult, provided for in the Penal Code. Slander occurs when someone falsely attributes to another person a fact defined as a crime. Injury occurs when there is an offense to someone’s dignity or decorum. In the case in question, Van Hattem called delegate Fábio Shor a “coward” and said he acted as a “bandit” and “outlaw.”

These statements were made both in the gallery of the Chamber of Deputies and in publications on social networks. This detail may aggravate the sentence if the deputy is convicted at the end of the criminal process in the Supreme Court. Disclosure in wide-ranging media is considered a factor that increases the offensive potential of words. The defense of the parliamentary has not yet been publicly expressed about the minister's vote.

Source of criticism: arrest of former advisor

Van Hattem’s criticism came after delegate Fábio Shor signed a request for arrest against Filipe Martins, a former adviser to Jair Bolsonaro, alleging a risk of escape. The report mentioned an alleged entry of Martins into the Estados Unidos in December 2022. However, the defense proved that the immigration record was false and that Martins was in Paraná at that time.

In the face of inconsistency, Van Hattem accused the police officer of deliberately producing fraudulent reports. The deputy used the Chamber's tribune to criticize the delegate's performance and repeated the accusations on his social networks. The PGR, however, argues that the wrong immigration documents do not prove that the delegate personally fabricated the falsehood. For the prosecution, the failure may have originated in other sectors of the investigation, without misconduct on the part of Shor.

What the Attorney General says

The Attorney General’s Office maintains that Van Hattem’s statements have exceeded the limits of political criticism and invaded the personal sphere of the delegate. By calling Shor a 'coward', 'bandit' and 'outlaw', the parliamentarian would have committed insult, as it offended the dignity of the public servant. The accusation of fabricating fraudulent reports would amount to slander, for falsely attributing a crime to the delegate.

For the PGR, parliamentary immunity is not absolute and does not protect demonstrations that constitute crimes against honor. The body points out that the offenses were uttered outside the strict exercise of the mandate, especially on social networks. The complaint was initially accepted by the rapporteur, Minister Flávio Dino, who considered that there were sufficient evidences of authorship and materiality. Now it is up to the plenary of the STF to decide whether to turn the deputy into a defendant.

Next steps in the Supreme

With Dino's vote, the case is still under consideration by the other ministers of the Court. There is no set deadline for the trial, which can take place in person or in the virtual plenary. If the majority of ministers follow the rapporteur, Marcel van Hattem will become a defendant and will respond to a criminal action. From there, the procedural instruction phase will begin, with the collection of evidence and testimonies.

The Member may make a preliminary defence and contest the charges. If convicted, the penalties for slander and insult may vary from detention to detention, depending on the circumstances. The fact that the offenses have been disclosed on social networks can increase the penalty by up to a third, as provided by the Penal Code. Van Hattem's defence has yet to comment on the minister's vote.

Repercussions and political context

The case comes at a time of tension between the Legislative and the Judiciary. In recent years, the STF has tried several lawsuits involving parliamentarians for statements against authorities. The decision on Van Hattem could set an important precedent for the limits of parliamentary immunity. Experts heard by the report point out that the Court has adopted a more rigid stance regarding speeches that configure crimes against honor.

On the other hand, allies of the deputy argue that criticisms are part of the political debate and should not be criminalized. Van Hatten himself stated on previous occasions that his speeches were "in the heat of the moment" and that he had no intention of personally offending the delegate. The source did not detail whether the MP intends to retract or make a formal apology.

The Boca no Trombone Portal will continue to monitor the case in the STF. The final decision of the ministers may come in the coming weeks, depending on the agenda of the Court. In the meantime, the deputy continues in the exercise of the mandate, without any restriction imposed by the Justice so far.

Read Also

Fachin maintains preventive detention of Daniel Vorcaro

Deputy promises impeachment of ministers of STF

House votes on bill that requires criminal record of people working with children

Font

www.gazetadopovo.com

Tags
Want to see BnT more often on Google?
Redação BnT
Author
Redação BnT
Equipe de jornalismo do BnT Online, cobrindo Ponta Grossa e os Campos Gerais.
See all stories →
Advertisement
Advertisement
Related news
Web Stories
All →
VideosMore videos you might like
BnT TV →
Part of the network
BnT OnlineNews portalCampos GeraisTravel appRádio BnTRadio · live
Viva Campos GeraisLong live Campos Gerais