Federal Deputy Promises Impeachment of STF Ministers
The federal deputy Marcel van Hattem strongly criticized the performance of the STF and promised impeachment of ministers. In a participation in a program, he stated that he will not bend to supposed blackmails and that parliamentary immunity protects him.

The federal deputy Marcel van Hattem (NOVO-RS) stated that, by taking over as senator, he will work to make possible the impeachment of ministers of the Supremo Tribunal Federal (STF). The statement was given in special participation in a program, in which the parliamentary also criticized the Attorney General of the Republic (PGR) and defended parliamentary immunity.
Van Hattem responds to a PGR representation for statements against Federal Police Delegate Fábio Alvarez Shor. At the time, the parliamentarian called the delegate an “abusor of authority” and accused him of producing fraudulent reports to base preventive arrests. For the PGR, these statements exceeded the right of criticism.
Understand the case and the reaction
The PGR understood that Van Hattem’s remarks against the PF’s delegate constituted excess. However, the deputy states that he is protected by the parliamentary immunity provided for in Constituição Federal.
Article 53 of the Magna Carta guarantees that deputies and senators are inviolable, civilly and criminally, by any of their opinions, words and votes. Van Hattem argues that only the House Ethics Council could assess his conduct.
“The only body that could act against a parliamentarian, in his words and votes, is the Ethics Council of the House. Never an external body, never the STF," the MP said in the program.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=888uVLeYXT8
Video: YouTube | Source: www.gazetadopovo.com.br
Lawyer warns of 'attempt to shut up'
The lawyer Enio Viterbo also spoke about the case. For him, the PGR action aims to intimidate the parliamentary, who is one of the main defenders of the impeachment of ministers of the STF in Congress.
“What you want to do is hold van Hattem hostage to the rotten band of the Federal Senate. He is the Senator who most vocalizes the issue of impeachment. It is an attempt to silence the senator,” Viterbo warns.
The jurist’s speech reinforces the thesis that there is an articulation to contain the advance of guidelines that displease the judiciary’s summit. Van Hattem, for his part, says he will not back down.
Member of Parliament Promises Impeachment of Ministers
In relation to a supposed blackmail of the Court, the deputy says that it will not bend. “If that’s the intention, it won’t work. I will take office as Senator and help elect Rogério Marinho (PL) as President. We will carry out, yes, the impeachment of ministers," says the parliamentarian.
The statement indicates that Van Hattem intends to use his future seat in the Senate to guide the removal of ministers from the STF. The process of impeachment of Supreme Court ministers is provided for in the Constitution, but has never been completed in recent history.
He did not specify which ministers would be targeted or under what circumstances the process would be opened. The source did not detail the next steps.
Parliamentary immunity under discussion
Parliamentary immunity is a pillar of the democratic rule of law. It ensures that lawmakers can exercise their mandate without fear of judicial retaliation for their opinions and votes.
However, the scope of such protection is often questioned when statements by parliamentarians reach the honor of others. The PGR understands that, in the case of Van Hattem, there was excess.
The deputy, on the other hand, argues that criticism of public agents, such as delegates of the PF, is an essential part of parliamentary supervision. For him, the attempt to frame it is an affront to the separation of Powers.
What the Constitution Says
Article 53 of the Constituição Federal is clear in establishing that deputies and senators are inviolable by their opinions, words and votes. This protection, however, is not absolute and can be relativized in cases of crimes against honor, such as slander and defamation.
The jurisprudence of the STF has swung over the limits of parliamentary immunity. In some trials, the Court held that protection does not achieve personal offenses unrelated to the mandate.
In the case of Van Hatten, it will be up to the courts to decide whether or not statements against the delegate are covered by immunity. The source did not detail the progress of the process.
Repercussions and next steps
Van Hattem’s talk about impeachment of ministers should intensify the debate in Congress. The issue is sensitive and divides opinions between parliamentarians from the governmental base and the opposition.
In the meantime, the MP is still campaigning for the Senate. He promised, if elected, to support the candidacy of Rogerio Marinho for the presidency of the House. Marine is from PL, party of former president Jair Bolsonaro.
The source did not detail when Van Hattem will take office as senator, nor is there a planned date for the analysis of the representation of the PGR. The Boca no Trombone Portal will continue to follow the case and bring updates as new information is released.
Read Also
Opposition to launch names for House of Representatives in 2027
MPs try to overthrow Motta in the House in 2027
Elizabeth will have to ‘catch the shards’ of outsourcing the school snack, by Gleidson Carlos
Font
www.gazetadopovo.com















