SUNDAY · 22 NOV 2026Ponta Grossa 22°C 🌦️
Advertisement
World

Gilmar admits excessive exposure in STF and asks for self-restraint

The minister Gilmar Mendes, dean of the STF, admitted that the Court may have become too important and that there is a lack of self-restraint. In an interview, he also commented on the crisis at Banco Master and the polarization around the Judiciary.

Gilmar admite excesso de exposição no STF e pede autocontenção
Crédito: Reprodução
Advertisement

Minister Gilmar Mendes, dean of Supremo Tribunal Federal (STF), acknowledged that the Court may have become "too important" and that "maybe self-restraint is lacking." The statement was given in an interview with an Argentine program, in which the magistrate reflected on the limits of the Judiciary and the recent wear on the public image of the Supreme Court.

Asked about the political clashes and controversies involving ministers appointed by different governments, Gilmar said that the members of the Court themselves reflect on the limits of their actions. “Maybe we have become too important, even because the path to triggering the court is so open that, at every moment, it is called upon to intervene. Perhaps there is a lack of self-restraint,” the magistrate said.

Comparison with the German Court and permanent judicialization

Formed in Germany, the dean compared the Brazilian Court to the German Constitutional Court and pointed out that the ease of access to the Supreme Court means that the Judiciary is continuously activated to arbitrate disputes that arise in the political arena. By expanding the role of legitimized to include political parties, trade union confederations and class entities of national scope, the constitutional text created, in the vision of the dean, a scenario of "permanent judicialization" in the country.

The magistrate considered, however, that the escalation of exposure of the Supreme in recent years was also driven by exceptional institutional crises, especially during the government of Jair Bolsonaro (PL), which maintained several clashes with the Supreme. This action, according to the dean, broadened the institutional recognition of the STF, but provoked a frontal reaction of bolsonaristas sectors, which began to attack the Court in the streets and question the integrity of the electoral system in 2022.

Tweet by @Metropoles

@Metropoles via X/Twitter

Attempts to strike and polarize

Tensions led to the attempted coup d’état and the invasion of the headquarters of the Três Poderes on January 8, 2022, an episode that led the STF to apply severe sentences and condemn the former president and four generals, deepening the polarization around the Judiciary. "Four generals have been convicted. Bolsonaro was convicted. This has provoked, on the one hand, applause, but also unrest in a very divided and very polarized country. Therefore, this is a data for a deeper analysis," he added.

Banco Master crisis and regulation

In the interview, Gilmar Mendes also spoke about the crisis involving Banco Master and banker Daniel Vorcaro. According to him, the episode stems from a failure of supervision and regulation of the financial system, and should not be attributed to the Três Poderes. According to the magistrate, the institution has marketed certificates through other major banks over a long period, which requires a broader analysis of the performance of regulatory bodies, in a context that involves parliamentarians, media executives and representatives of Banco Central.

In addressing the episode that gained strong repercussions in the public debate, Gilmar Mendes mentioned the emergence of indications that some ministers could have benefited, in addition to the reference to a contract involving the wife of minister Alexandre de Moraes. The dean lamented the scope of the controversy and noted that the Supreme Court ended up gaining a pronounced prominence, becoming a central point in the political and institutional discussions about the case.

The statements of Gilmar Mendes rekindle the debate on the role of STF in Brazilian democracy and the limits of judicial action in a scenario of strong political polarization. The minister did not detail what self-containment measures could be adopted, but signalled that the Court is attentive to criticism and willing to reflect on its own conduct.

Read Also

Socialist Utopia led Australians to Paraguay 130 years ago

Trump criticizes EU spending on Ukraine, Zelenskiy says

Russian missiles crash in Poland and drone hits ship

Font

Metropoles.com

interview with the Argentinian program Modo Fontevecchia, conducted by journalist Jo (www.profil.com)

Tags
Want to see BnT more often on Google?
Redação BnT
Author
Redação BnT
Equipe de jornalismo do BnT Online, cobrindo Ponta Grossa e os Campos Gerais.
See all stories →
Advertisement
Advertisement
Related news
Web Stories
All →
VideosMore videos you might like
BnT TV →
Part of the network
BnT OnlineNews portalCampos GeraisTravel appRádio BnTRadio · live
Viva Campos GeraisLong live Campos Gerais