Gilmar downplays Mendonça's gesture and advocates plenary for Master case
The minister Gilmar Mendes, dean of the Supreme Federal Court, downplayed his colleague André Mendonça's gesture and argued that the case involving the Master bank should be taken to the court's plenary, instead of remaining in the Second Chamber. The statement was made on Friday (20), during a conversation with journalists.

Minister Gilmar Mendes, dean of Supremo Tribunal Federal (STF), downplayed the gesture of colleague André Mendonça and argued that the case involving banco Master be taken to the plenary of the Court, rather than remain in the Second Class. The statement was made on Friday (20), during a conversation with journalists. According to Gilmar, the debate is up to the rapporteur, but the decision does not resolve the substantive issue.
“It is a discussion that falls, perhaps, to those who are now with the report itself, in the case of President Fachin. I do not see any problem if there is this kind of decision and I also do not see that this solves the question, it is necessary to actually examine the contents,” said the dean.
Gilmar did not mention the possibility of the other ministers requesting the withdrawal of secrecy, as Mendonça did. But he argued that the case should be taken to the plenary of the Court instead of remaining in the Second Class. The movement tends to equalize situations involving suspicions of quite different natures and severities and occurs amid the dispute over who should conduct the investigations.
Dispute over the Master case report
It is not the first time that Gilmar acts to remove from Mendonça the protagonism in the investigation. In September, the dean had already advocated that the procedures related to Moraes and Mendonça be gathered and submitted to a new rapporteur draw. The proposal did not advance, but highlighted the tension behind the scenes of the STF.
The PF report did not identify direct conversations between Mendonça and Vorcaro. 11 references to the minister were found in the material extracted from the banker’s cell phone, but without elements that indicate a relationship similar to that that appears in the counts involving other members of the Supreme Court. The absence of direct dialogue weakens the thesis of deeper involvement of the minister in the case.
The other three reports sent to the Attorney General's Office (PGR) concern Alexandre de Moraes, Dias Toffoli and Kassio Nunes Marques. Each has a different degree of closeness to the banker, which makes the comparison between the cases delicate and reinforces the argument that not all can be treated equally.
Differences between the ministers investigated
The difference between the cases is especially relevant in relation to Moraes. The material gathered by PF points to messages attributed to the minister and the former banker at a time when the Master was trying to prevent the advancement of investigations and make possible a sale of a stake in the bank to BRB. This context suggests a more direct and potentially more compromising interaction than the one verified in the case of Mendonça.
The material also records a second proposal, of R$ 50 million, which provided for payments partially linked to quotas of a jet and a helicopter. According to the bank, this proposal was neither accepted nor signed. The mention of values and luxury goods raises the degree of attention on the case, even if the defense denies any formal agreement.
For Gilmar, bringing together all the cases in plenary would allow for a more uniform analysis, but it could also dilute the specifics of each investigation. The source did not specify whether the Dean intended to formalize a request to that effect or whether he would await the motion of the rapporteur.
What to expect from the next steps
The expectation is that the president of the STF, Minister Edson Fachin, decides whether to keep the case in the Second Class or refer it to the plenary. The source did not detail deadlines for this definition. In the meantime, the PGR analyzes the reports submitted and can request additional diligence or archive extracts of the investigations.
The outcome of the Master case will have a direct impact on the image of the court and the public’s confidence in the impartiality of the ministers. The way the STF will conduct the counts involving its own members will be closely observed by lawyers and society.
The Boca no Trombone Portal will continue to track the developments and will bring new information as confirmed by official sources.
Read Also
Lula: economic promises of 2022 and what did not come out
Fachin tries to advance reforms on the STF before the recess
Lula’s Army Channel Loses 1.4 Million After Crash
Font
www.gazetadopovo.com















